Grothe vs Tebow?

[PitBull]

starting tebow will win you a heisman

starting grothe will win you a national championship

[slowdown]

Grothe vs the Rutgers defense is the more relevant issue right now

[usfgrad84]

I usually don't get invovled in this type of deabte, but I will make just one comment.  Stats are nice, but at crunch time our QB seems to find a way to win.  Grothe is more valuable.  Stats are nice, but leadeship is most important.

[smazza]

grothe is top player as of today

he is legimate heisman canditate

but he must continue to perform and do it on thursday when entire world will be watching

[Bull Dozer]

Grothe vs the Rutgers defense is the more relevant issue right now

Yup and these comparisions are worthless as you will never be able to switch them to see how they would work if the situations were reversed.  That would be the only way to get a true comparison because they would be playing each others schedules.  They are both great Young QB's with great futures and you can't really go wrong with either one. 

[Rabbi Bull]

Grothe won AT Auburn, Tebow lost AT Home to Auburn, nuff said.

[ptimario]

I agree to drop this conversation.

They'll never get to play each other so they're not worth comparing.

They will play each other their senior years.

no they don't. they will both be seniors in 2009. bulls and gaytors play in 2010.

[GoLo Baby!!!]

Grothe's got more style in his game. Mobility, agility, quickness with power. AND HE CAN THROW THAT BALL!!! Grothe is the most underrated QB in the Bigs East... maybe the nation.

[WWMJD]

I agree to drop this conversation.

They'll never get to play each other so they're not worth comparing.

They will play each other their senior years.

no they don't. they will both be seniors in 2009. bulls and gaytors play in 2010.

Yes I'm an idiot.  Simple math escapes me sometimes.

[1AUfan]

I have watched both of these guys, and it seems to me that Tebow wants (or needs) to be the center of attention.  He only handed the ball to the RB five times against Auburn.  Grothe seems to be a team player, and the leader of your offense.  Therefore, I'd take Grothe over Super T anyday.